The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case that could redefine when individuals can sue the federal government for law enforcement mistakes. The case, Martin v. United States, arises from a botched 2015 FBI SWAT raid in Georgia, where federal agents mistakenly stormed the wrong home, terrifying an innocent family.
At the heart of the case is whether the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) allows victims of wrongful raids to sue the government or whether the Supremacy Clause and the “discretionary function” exception protect federal agents from liability.
This case has broad implications for law enforcement accountability and the rights of citizens caught in government errors. If the Court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, it could set a precedent for holding federal agencies liable for wrongful police actions.
The Case: A Raid Gone Wrong
In the early hours of a 2015 no-knock raid, an FBI SWAT team breached the home of Curtrina Martin and Hilliard Cliatt in suburban Atlanta. The raid was meant for a known gang member, Joseph Riley, whose home was nearby but located on a different street with a different house number.
The FBI stormed the wrong house, using a flashbang grenade—a powerful device designed to stun suspects with an intense burst of light and noise. The couple was confronted at gunpoint, with Cliatt handcuffed and Martin caught partially dressed.
When agents realized their mistake, they apologized and promised to handle property repairs, but the psychological and emotional damage had already been done.
Legal Questions Before the Supreme Court
The plaintiffs filed a lawsuit under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), arguing that the government should be held liable for:
✅ False arrest
✅ False imprisonment
✅ Negligence
✅ Assault and battery
However, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed their claims, ruling that the “discretionary function” exception shielded the FBI from liability. This exception prevents lawsuits against the government for actions taken in the course of discretionary decision-making, such as law enforcement operations.
The Supreme Court will now decide:
1️⃣ Does the Supremacy Clause protect federal agents from state law claims in mistaken raids?
2️⃣ Does the discretionary function exception apply to wrongful police actions?
The ruling could reshape law enforcement accountability and determine whether victims of mistaken federal police actions have any recourse in court.
#SupremeCourt #SWATRaid #PoliceAccountability #CivilRights #FBI #LawEnforcement #LegalNews #FederalImmunity #FTCA
Source: https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/01/justices-take-up-case-on-right-to-sue-over-mistaken-swat-raid/
lawrota.com 
Leave a comment